Top 15 Albums (plus 54 others)
Stephen over at the excellent music blog 1001albumsin10years threw out this challenge:
“Happy September to all,
On September 15th, many bloggers in this community (myself included) are planning to post about their “Top 15 Albums.”
I love a good list, especially ones that could change by the hour.
So an open invite, the more posts the merrier: on Tuesday, September 15th, let’s write/read/talk Top 15s, looking forward to it!”
I, of course, accept! In order to complete this insanely difficult task I came up with a few simple rules to make life easier on myself. One, no “big 4” bands allowed in the top 15. So, even though The Beatles, The Stones, The Beach Boys and The Who have albums that I absolutely adore you will not see them in the top 15. We all know how good they are, no need to rehash their brilliance. Two, no compilations. Three, only one album per band. This one was more difficult as you can imagine. Five: I came up with a total of 69 (Freudian?), so I am listing the remaining 54, just because they deserve to be there. Lastly, I stuck to the Rock/Pop genre, so no Jazz, classical, Sinatra (sigh…), etc. The following are my top albums today, as opposed to next week, which would be assuredly different. Except for the top slot. That ain’t goin’ nowhere.
Other than that, I’d like to thank Stephen for the idea and the prompt, and ask you to head on over to his site when you’re done here to see what he has listed! The link is over there on the right. Oh, and as always, I’d like to read your opinions, positive and negative, and if you’re so inclined to do so, your top 15 list as well. Cheers!
#1. Boo Radleys, Giant Steps: This album has remained in my #1 slot since about 1994, and I don’t see it budging from its perch anytime soon. It’s the most fantastic example of modern psychedelic pop I have ever heard. The musical ideas are varied in style and legion in number, and the songs that Martin Carr wrote for this album are on another level altogether. Imagine The Jesus and Mary Chain, The Beach Boys, The Beatles, and Massive Attack in a studio together with George Martin holding everything together as head knob twiddler and you still won’t be close to describing what this masterpiece sounds like.
#2. Prefab Sprout, Steve McQueen: Or as I knew it when it was first released in North America, “Two Wheels Good”. I am still unable to separate the lush production of Thomas Dolby from the amazing songs of Paddy McAloon; both are equally responsible for the success of this recording. The lyrics are some of the best I’ve ever heard, too; clever, but not to the point of arrogance.
#3. Nick Lowe, Jesus Of Cool: This is the better title, but the other one describes the music much better: Pure Pop For Now People. A little new wave, a little roots, a little pub rock (from his time with Brinsley Schwarz, I suppose), a little punk, all fantastic.
#4. Underworld, Dubnobasswithmyheadman: In my opinion the best electronic album of the last 30 years. The kings of the slow burn, each song an epic in miniature, complete with lyrics that, at worst, make you go “WTF?” and at best add to the bliss.
#5. Supertramp, Breakfast In America: Why Steely Dan has seen a critical reevaluation and not Supertramp is beyond me. The four albums from Crime Of The Century to this, in 1979, are some of the finest sophisto-pop/progressive music moments ever recorded. Period. And this is their masterpiece.
#6. Clash, Sandinista!: OK, so I’ll concede side 6 (of the original vinyl) is mostly crap. Sides 1-5, however, well lets just say I’d put the best of them against the best of the debut or London Calling. That should be a pretty good indication of how I feel about this record. The Clash at their most fearlessly progressive.
#7. XTC, Skylarking: The cliché holds true: “A pastoral masterpiece of British songcraft.” Still XTC’s best record, and Grass one of Colin Moulding’s finest moments.
#8. Happy Mondays, Pills, Thrills and Bellyaches: If this were a “Best Albums Of The ‘90’s” list this would be in the top 3. Manchester hooligan druggies discover the dance floor and create an album that still sounds fresh 25 years on.
#9. Super Furry Animals, Guerrilla: I could have picked any SFA album and I would have been justified, but this is the one I listen to front to back the most often, so here it is! More of an electronic tinge than some of the others, but the weirdness remains, and the hooks are aplenty. Abfab!
#10. Mercury Rev, Deserters Songs: Have you ever been to Disneyland whilst tripping on acid? Me neither, but I’d imagine the soundtrack would sound something like this.
#11. Flaming Lips, Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots: I bought this album because I fell in love with the cover, and after listening to it dozens of times I quickly became a super fan. I bought and devoured everything from The great Soft Bulletin to Embryonic, and then the floor fell out. But at least we have this record, to me the Flaming Lips most poignant and experimental moment.
#12. Pulp, Different Class: Jarvis Cocker and his merry crew never aligned themselves with the Britpop movement, yet they were really the most British of all the bands from this time frame (or maybe tied with Blur). Common People just might be my favorite song of the 1990’s, just the perfect anthem for that decade. It is one of those rare perfect 10 albums and I still get chills whenever I listen to it.
#13. Jazz Butcher, A Scandal In Bohemia: I was obsessed with everything the Jazz Butcher recorded in the 1980’s and my obsession hasn’t waned one bit. I think that Pat Fish and Max Eider are two of the most criminally underrated songwriters, and they are still doing it and doing it well. A lot of the JB’s best songs of the 1980’s were scattered around various EP’s, singles and compilations, but A Scandal In Bohemia is a perfect pop moment where everything just fit like a glove.
#14. The Kinks, Something Else: It’s the one with Waterloo Sunset on it. C’mon…what else do you need?
#15. Queen, Sheer Heart Attack: A Queen album had to make the top 15, and this is my favorite. News Of The World, back in 1977, was where I started my obsession with Queen, and I still own virtually everything they ever did while Freddie was alive, but SHA was where I truly think the band came into their own. The prog/boogie of Brighton Rock,, the anthemic sing along Now I’m Here, the rock/pomp of Killer Queen, the proto-thrash of Stone Cold Crazy…just a fantastically creative record all around.
And the rest…
The Dead Kennedys, Plastic Surgery Disasters
Beatles, Revolver
The Who, Tommy
Beach Boys, Pet Sounds
Primal Scream, Screamadelica
Wilco, Summerteeth
Saint Etienne, So Tough
Simple Minds, New Gold Dream
Sloan, Never Hear The End Of It
Specials, More Specials
Squeeze, Argybargy
Stereolab, Emperor Tomato Ketchup
Steve Miller Band, Sailor
Stone Roses, Stone Roses
Stranglers, The Raven
Supergrass, In It For The Money
Television, Marquee Moon
Thomas Dolby, The Golden Age Of Wireless
Velvet Underground, Velvet Underground and Nico
Waterboys, Fisherman’s Blues
The Who, Tommy
Woodentops, Giant
Zombies, Odyssey and Oracle
Smiths, Smiths
Housemartins, London 0, Hull 4
Hawkwind, Space Ritual
Blur, The Great Escape
Rush, Moving Pictures
AC/DC, High Voltage
Happy New Order, Power, Corruption and Lies
David Bowie, Hunky Dory
E.L.O., New World Record
English Beat, I Just Can’t Stop It
Funkadelic, One Nation Under A Groove
Paul McCartney, Band On The Run
10cc, The Original Soundtrack
Super Furry Animals, Guerrilla
Hall and Oates, Abandoned Luncheonette
Icicle Works, Icicle Works
Paul Weller, Paul Weller
Lou Reed, Transformer
Men Without Hats, Rhythm Of Youth
Motorhead, Ace Of Spades
Thin Lizzy, Jailbreak
My Morning Jacket, Z
Orange Juice, You Can’t Hide Your Love Forever
Orchestral Maneuvres In The Dark, Dazzle Ships
Pet Shop Boys, Introspective
Pink Floyd, Animals
The Pogues, Rum Sodomy and the Lash
Pop Will Eat Itself, Cure For Sanity
Steven Wilson, The Raven That Refused To Sing
Psychedelic Furs, Forever Now
Ramones, Rocket To Russia
Roxy Music, Country Life
Hey Ian…Here goes 🙂
Doors – The Soft Parade
Sweet – Desolation Boulevard (US)
Who – Who’s Next (yes I’m tired of it, but still…)
The The – Mind Bomb
Flipper – Gone Fishin’
Cheap Trick – At Budokan
Pearl Jam – Ten
Led Zeppelin – Led Zeppelin II
Doors – Strange Days
Deep Purple – Made in Japan
Woodentops – Giant
U2 – The Joshua Tree
R.E.M. – Life’s Rich Pageant
Police – Ghost in the Machine
Blur – 13
I could easily switch in 2 or 3 top records from Jimi Hendrix. Jethro Tull, B-52s, Pixies, Tori Amos, XTC, into the list above. And I know there are numerous other great artists that I’ve never found the time to give a fair shake, or that I’m going blank on right now as I write. Doors are my ATF. I can’t believe Jimi is not on my list above but I’ll keep the list as is anyway, I’m sure he don’t mind,
Beatles? The most important band in modern music history with little question, yet I never listened to a Beatles record I really loved or “wowed!” to…I tried Abbey Road seriously with several spins, but I just wasn’t loving it (at the time anyway). and we had the “late era” greatest hits record at home and it was played quite a bit. I feel kind of the same about the Stones.
Hey Paul, what a terrific list. Especially glad to see The The’s Dusk on there instead of Mind Bomb (the critics go-to The The LP), and double bonus SUPER points for Giant!
Ahh Ian..you read it wrong! I actually agree with these critics and feel “Mind Bomb” is Matt Johnson’s peak outing…but Dusk is fantastic also and The The never missed with any of their releases. Matt incidentally has some new soundtrack material out, serious fans will need it and can find it on the artist site (I’m just waiting for my job to come through before I start making some new purchases).
Woodentops and Giant were a lucky discovery for me..via the XTC fanzine when I heard about this emergent band recording an EP produced by Andy Partridge and decided “ok I’ll check that out”. The disk certainly is a unique gem and has the continuity, from start to end, the sort of thing that artists at a peak and in the zone manage to accomplish.
Writing of zone records..I’ve never been the biggest Aerosmith fan..but Rocks is certainly one of the greatest Peak Artist rock recordings ever..I think it’s one that deserves a nod somewhere from somebody if it’s not getting it now 🙂
Different Class was a last minute cut for me, what a beautiful record!
Terrific list Ian – great point about some artists like supertramp being due for a critical re-evaluation. Like Hall & Oates in your bonus list, they don’t get the credit they deserve!
Thanks for the words of support for The ‘Tramp, Stephen. They seem to be one of those forgotten bands of the ’70’s, but due to some well placed soundtrack choices (Magnolia, in particular) and some deluxe reissues over the last few years I’m hopeful they’ll one day get the credit they deserve. And, yes, Different Class is just a transcendent record.
I’ll take #4, 8 and 12 please! Great to hear some Underworld love, I bought the vinyl for the first time just before Christmas and it sounds monstrously good.
Good to see we’ve got some overlap! Dubnobass…is an amazing listen (still), but I’m sad to say I have never heard it on vinyl.
I also love Second Toughest too and the first Leftfield … see, it’s all a big infinity trap!!
Second Toughest Is getting the deluxe treatment in a couple of months!
I’m looking now through your complete list…a few artists I hadn’t thought much about for a long time honestly! Actually, a lot of these I haven’t listened to at all, or given a serious chance. My life has been focused on many different things over the years, sometimes music listening has taken a back seat to other interests or problems in my life. I did have Icicle Works back in the day..I didn’t get it at all (at least not at the time I gave it a few spins and gave up). Perhaps because that was back when I was suffering from “XTC Fever” for about 5 years of my life (1982 – 86), I actually found it hard to connect with most other music..even U2 paled by comparison for me. I thought “War” was boring at the time, almost all I wanted to listen to during 1984 was The Big Express. Strange but I’m kind of an odd bird.
My life and tastes changed over time, and now I actually favor U2 over XTC if someone asked me to compare…perhaps because esoterically the faith-based spiritual and mysterious element of the Dublin band, as opposed to the XTC atheistic ethos, is far more significant for this world (esoterica also having become important to me personally, in a way it wasn’t back when I might have been the world’s biggest XTC fan). And the fact that U2 has been a major performing act for decades while XTC retired early on from live performance, irregardless of record sales and popularity, puts points in U2’s corner. But I still appreciate and respect the weird-genius-hermit XTC outfit and their catalog immensely.
No B-52’s? Or did I miss it? Just wondering. They would easily get onto my own Top 50 (probably Cosmic Thing, or alternatively Wild Planet).
Not a huge B52s fan, Paul, sad to say. I enjoy their early stuff a lot, but they wouldn’t make it in my top list. I’d really recommend giving the debut by Icicle a Works another spin. I think you’ll find it more palatable than when it came out.
My opinions on esoterica and U2 are just those, feeling that the esoteric element is significant and real, and important for soul of the world at large. Band ethos, and esoteric or non-esoteric sometimes is a part of that, often does result in debates (Nirvana vs. Pearl Jam?) that can’t be avoided sometimes..and it’s not a bad thing to discuss, not necessarily on this kind of site though 🙂
Oh I think this is the perfect place to discuss such things, Paul, and I’m glad you bring them up.
Pingback: Top 15 Albums | 1001albumsin10years
I like this list a lot. I had considered Deserter’s Songs and the Yoshimi for mine, but ultimately decided against both at the last minute. Bunch of other albums in there that I’m discovering (Breakfast in America) and rediscovering (Different Class and all the SFA stuff I haven’t listened to in a while!), too. Nice one.
Thanks, J, I appreciate it. Some albums just get under your skin and never leave, and Deserters Songs and Yoshimi remain attached to my psyche like a stubborn barnacle. Have fun in rediscovering SFA, it’s a wild ride, and I hope you delve deeper into Supertramp’s back catalog, maybe starting with Crime Of The Century?
Pingback: Fifteen on the Fifteenth: Favourite Albums | Resurrection Songs
Now that’s a list! I have a feeling we could swap record collections and go a long time before either one of us would notice.
Brian I am sure we wouldn’t notice a thing! Thanks for the nice comment,
My entries for what they’re worth…
The Replacements – Tim
Tommy Keene – Songs from the Film
The Smithereens – Especially for You
The Cure – Disintegration
Marshall Crenshaw – Marshall Crenshaw
Jesus and Mary Chain – Darklands
Depeche Mode – Black Celebration
The Wild Swans – Bringing Home The Ashes
The Smiths – The Queen Is Dead
Echo & the Bunnymen – Ocean Rain
Husker Du – Zen Arcade
Let’s Active – Every Dog Has His Day
Scritti Politti – Cupid & Psyche 85
The Clash – London Calling
Tears For Fears – The Hurting
Thanks!!
Excellent, excellent list. I always forget about Scritti Politti, dammit! And cheers for choosing Darklands over the more critically acceptable Psychocandy.
Great list! Different Class is definitely in my upper echelon, as are Skylarking, Sandanista! and Happy Mondays. So many in the close… section to comment on as well.
Hi Greg, thank you. Yeah, I still never tire of listening to Different Class, but in reality I almost enjoy His n Hers and This Is Hardcore equally well.
Pingback: Top 15 On The 15th | Tangled Up In Music
Pingback: My Top 15 Albums Of All Time | Living a Beautiful Life
Enjoyed your list (which I found thanks to Danica). I have about half of your 15 and 28 of the others, but not your #1. As I love psychedelia, this sounds like one to investigate. Cheers.
Hi VC! Love your blog, read it all the time! Yeah, Danica is a sweetie for including my list in her link, and what a great blog she has as well, eh? I think you’ll really like Giant Steps, but I am so far past biased when it comes to this album I’m not sure anymore…
Very interesting collection. Won’t surprise you that I’m delighted to see ‘Skylarking’ and ‘Steve McQueen’ in there!
Thanks, Matt, I loved your list as well but was very surprised that a PF album didn’t make the cut (Jordan just outside the top). And, yes, Skylarking remains a perfect album in my opinion. It may not be the popular choice anymore (English settlement takes that crown), a bit like Sgt Peppers, but it’s still mine!
Respect, especially for Yoshimi (my #2).
Also, considering the title of your blog, I wonder what you think of this post I did a couple of years ago?
Thanks, Andy! I read your post on 80s songs and there is a lot of overlap. If I read things correctly I believe you’re from Australia? If so, one of my favorite albums from the 80s, Mars Needs Guitars by the Hoodoo Gurus is from there (I’m sure you know this). Also, while I wasn’t a child in the 90s I was in my early 20s and is actually probably my favorite decade for music (at least it is today); a ton of my top albums above are from that decade, maybe even more than the 80s!
I’ll add a link to your blog, if that’s ok. Really, really enjoyed your travel notes and photos on your tour of the USA. Interesting to read someone else’s opinion of your home. I look forward to perusing your blog some more in the future, and thanks for dropping by!
Pingback: Fifteen on the Fifteenth: Favourite Albums | Resurrection Songs